You are right, Division II is hard to do based on the fact of you don't know what the Freshman are really capable of at this point given they have not played a regular season game, trust me fall ball is much different from regular season.
With Anderson being #1, I liked them because they return Molly Child (.405, 14 HR, 53 RBI), Jessica Neidigh (.376, 6 HR, 25 RBI, 26 SB), Courtney Czentar (.313, 11 HR, 42 RBI), Rebecca Martin (.313, 7 HR,20 RBI), and Bri Cason (.287, 3 HR, 29 RBI). They are going to be a team that is going to drop a lot of bombs, then on the mound the return Lauren Rudesheim (16-4, 2.48 ERA) who will be their ace this year to go along with Augie Pena (8-2, 3.59 ERA) and Freshman, Chelsea Jones.
Limestone returns a lot from a team that finished with a good season last year so that is why they are my #2,
Francis Marion at #3 was a tough pick but I think they are a team who finished in the middle of the pack last year in the Peach Belt which is a great conference, I think if they good off to a good start in non conference play then they can have a good year, if they don't then uh oh.
Newberry is a team that I think has potential to have a good season, they return a lot of starters and will be battle tested early with a tough non conference slate
USC-Aiken did lose Kornegay but they still have Morgan there who I believe can get them to middle of the pack in the Peach Belt, once again early on will tell how good they are.
You mentioned Erskine, people are talking how impressed they are with Erskine on this message board and all over the place so that is why I ranked them so high, I think just like others they will find out how good they are early on.
Claflin at #7, I wanted to rank them higher but I want to see them play somebody, I like the Kinard guy and the job he has done recruiting there. They return 7 of 9 starters from a 43-8 team, but we will find out on February 15 how good they are when they travel to Newberry.
North Greenville and Coker are in the same boat, losing some of their best players who carried them and going through a rebuilding year in my opinion, I look for both of them to struggle a little bit this season.
Lander didn't look bad in the fall, but that was the fall and they have some points to prove before they get my vote to move up.
Southern Wesleyan, I don't know about the hire they made and how well she can do in her first year, they didn't bring a whole lot in and they weren't very good last year.
Benedict, do not play a tough non conference schedule so they will not be battle tested until they play Columbia College, but I do not expect much from them, from what I heard they do not have a pitcher who throws over 55.